Playing out of turn on an unallowable extra ball

[stevevt]

Interesting (?) discussion I just had with a player who was DQd for playing an extra ball out of turn

Warning: Text wall ahead, especially the stuff that I wrote. I’m mainly writing this to see if anyone thinks there are other arguments to be made that might have persuaded this player that the rule is fair. PlayerX: Well I told my girlfriend the “facts of the case” and she objectively came to the same conclusion that the rules are bullshit. Seems you could exploit it by getting an extra ball and walking away and let the next person play it and get DQ’ed. I know you’re gonna say they need to…